After 3 Years, Jury Convicts St. Louis Repo Murderer
More than three years after the murder of Jesse Jones, the case has finally reached a jury verdict. On November 12, 2026, a St. Louis jury found 30-year-old Dwayne Davis guilty of second-degree murder, first-degree robbery, two counts of armed criminal action and unlawful possession of a firearm.
Jones, who owned JJ’s Towing & Recovery and lived in Elsberry, Missouri, was killed on September 7, 2023, in the Hamilton Heights neighborhood of St. Louis. As we reported at the time, Jones had arrived to repossess a Jeep Grand Cherokee that was being rented by a woman who was apparently in the process of moving. In what his family described as a characteristic act of kindness, Jones agreed to help her by transporting her and her belongings to a family member’s location.
According to prosecutors, the woman contacted Davis, who subsequently confronted Jones in the 5900 block of Hamilton Terrace. Davis attempted to rob Jones and shot him when he did not immediately exit the Jeep. Jones died at the scene, and Davis fled in the vehicle.
The investigation quickly crossed state lines. The following day, investigators used a GPS tracking device installed in the Jeep to locate it in Cahokia, Illinois. When police attempted to stop Davis, he fled, eventually crashing the vehicle on the Poplar Street Bridge. Authorities reported that Davis threw a firearm from the bridge before being taken into custody. Investigators recovered the weapon and connected it to a cartridge casing found at the murder scene.
Perhaps one of the most significant details revealed in the prosecution’s announcement is that Davis later admitted to shooting Jones during a recorded police interview. Prosecutors also noted that Davis had previous felony convictions for robbery and unlawful possession of a firearm and was on parole when Jones was killed.
Davis was originally charged with first-degree murder. The jury ultimately returned a conviction for second-degree murder, along with the additional robbery and firearm-related convictions.
There is another part of this case that remains worth watching. The Jeep belonged to Cortrina Donaby, who was identified in earlier reporting as the woman renting the vehicle. In December 2023, the Riverfront Times reported that Donaby had also been charged with felony murder, robbery and armed criminal action. According to the original police allegations, she had contacted Davis about the repossession and was believed to have worked with him to intercept the vehicle. At the time, authorities reported that she had left Missouri and a warrant had been issued for her arrest. She remains a fugitive..
Davis is scheduled to be sentenced on January 15, 2027, in St. Louis Circuit Court. The case number is 2322-CR02119-01.
For those who remember our original coverage, Jesse’s death was particularly disturbing because of the circumstances surrounding it. He wasn’t simply performing a repossession assignment. He had gone out of his way to help someone, and that decision ultimately put him in the path of a man who intended to rob him.
His family previously described him as a kindhearted man who loved his work, his family and helping others. His sister’s recollections of his personality, including his trademark furry bear-foot slippers, gave the industry a glimpse of the person behind the headlines.
Three years later, a jury has delivered its verdict. While no conviction can undo what happened or return Jesse to his family, it does bring an important chapter of this case to a close.
Original Repo Buzz coverage: Fugitive Charged In St. Louis Repossessor’s Murder











